Ashley Kalkowski

DESTROYING BOULDERS / SPATIAL REFINEMENT M04

A closer
spatial check.

Keep the same steel specimen. Refine its mesh. Revisit six fixed frequencies without a retained-mode reduction.

Research direction: Ashley Kalkowski.
18 numerically valid direct solutions · both selected-set accuracy screens fail.
No physical or fracture tests.

Read the scope

SAME SPECIMEN / THREE MESHES / SIX FIXED SAMPLES

A bounded follow-up to M03.

The full-grid accuracy failure remains part of the record.

Completed meshes: n12 → n16 → n20
Original-grid indices: 0, 80, 130, 131, 132, 160
18 completed direct harmonic solutions

A SELECTED-SET CHECK DOES NOT VALIDATE THE FULL BAND
No frequency peak search or crack propagation is added.

20 mmUnchanged cube side length
1 NPrescribed force · peak
6Fixed original frequency samples
0Physical tests

01 / NARROW THE CLAIM

Refine where the comparison
needs another look.

M03 found large differences between two direct finite-element meshes across its original frequency grid. M04 is a bounded follow-up at six declared samples, including the prior sensitivity sample and its two immediate original-grid neighbors. The selections were frozen before the new solves.

Smaller absolute differences. Both selected-set accuracy screens still fail.

The largest scaled complex-compliance difference is 185.564% for n12 → n16 and 42.605% for n16 → n20. Both exceed the declared 5% threshold, with their maxima at original index 130 (129.876 kHz).

All 18 point records are numerically valid and all six n12 parent replays pass. Absolute response differences are smaller for the finer step at all six samples. That contraction does not establish a convergence order, known continuum error, full-band accuracy or device efficiency.

Six categorical sample positions show three mesh responses and two refinement-step differences. Maximum scaled differences are 185.56 and 42.61 percent; both fail the 5 percent criterion.
Actual saved scalar responses. Sample positions are categorical: the large unsolved gaps are not joined into a frequency-response curve. Figure provenance and checks; source, SVG and plotted CSV are in the executable core.
Frozen comparison screens; all use the declared 5% criterion.
QuantityScopeDifferenceOutcome
n12 → n16Maximum across the six fixed samples185.564%FAIL
n16 → n20Maximum across the six fixed samples42.605%FAIL
Complex compliance, n12 → n16Only the 20 kHz sample0.173%PASS
Volume/time RMS stress, n12 → n16Only the 20 kHz sample0.250%PASS
Complex compliance, n16 → n20Only the 20 kHz sample0.097%PASS
Volume/time RMS stress, n16 → n20Only the 20 kHz sample0.141%PASS

Three finer meshes do not automatically establish convergence. A comparison at six frequencies cannot bound response at the other original samples or between frequencies. Any contraction diagnostic remains a diagnostic; it is not a continuum-error bound.

READ THE SCALE / RETAIN THE DIAGNOSTIC

A fixed historical floor.
No new peak chosen after the run.

For each pair, the denominator is max(|Hfine(f)|, 1.612189244e-10 m/N). The floor is 1% of M03’s full-grid n12 direct-compliance peak. It was frozen before M04 and was not recomputed from these six points or from the new meshes.

At index 131, the two versions of the percentage differ.

The n16 → n20 difference is 14.6657% with the declared floor, versus 26.9641% when divided by the local fine response alone. Both are shown. The unfloored number is diagnostic; it is not an added acceptance gate. Neither percentage describes energy efficiency or fracture probability.

All six declared samples. The last column is |H16 − H20| / |H12 − H16|; values below one describe contraction only.
Original indexkHz12 → 16 scaled16 → 20 scaled16 → 20 unflooredFine floor active?Absolute-difference ratio
020.0000.173%0.097%0.097%No0.5622
8063.2464.557%2.616%2.616%No0.5894
130129.876185.564%42.605%45.960%Yes0.1738
131131.75962.586%14.666%26.964%Yes0.2343
132133.66924.354%7.790%21.890%Yes0.3199
160200.00044.110%15.661%57.898%Yes0.3550

The two refinement steps have different mesh-size ratios. These six contraction ratios are not a fitted convergence order or Richardson extrapolation. Passing the low-frequency checks does not validate a contiguous low-frequency band. Other stress differences remain diagnostics; there is no new band-wide stress gate.

02 / SHOW AN ACTUAL SAVED FIELD

One harmonic field.
Its display scale made explicit.

The retained field is the n20 solution at original index 131, at 131.759 kHz. Its 9,261 nodes and 4,800 boundary triangles come from the actual 48,000-tetrahedron specimen mesh. The geometry shown is undeformed, with its 20 mm dimensions preserved.

The undeformed 20 millimetre n20 cube is colored using its saved complex-displacement norm at 131.759 kilohertz. The fixed bottom is dark, while some upper surface regions have larger norms, under one nanometre in this ideal linear calculation.
Actual retained numerical field; no geometric exaggeration. The node quantity is √(Σj|Uj|²), and each surface triangle uses the mean of its three vertex values. Colors are in nanometres. This component-complex norm is not guaranteed to equal the instantaneous vector peak. The underlying NPZ, all 4,800 triangle-color values and exact plot source are in the core archive.

Color is a response quantity from the saved linear harmonic solution. It is not damage, strength, a crack path or a measured displacement. Rendering regenerates the geometry and reads the retained field; it performs zero new FEM solves. The seventeen other M04 full fields were computed but not retained; all eighteen scalar records remain available.

03 / PRESERVE THE MODEL BOUNDARIES

The ideal load remains
an untested interface.

The specimen assumptions carry forward. This edition does not establish a delivery device, material hardness, fracture strength or mining throughput.

GEOMETRY / MATERIAL

One linear steel cube.

The same isotropic 20 mm specimen, fixed bottom face, elastic properties and assumed damping are retained. There is no damage law, plasticity, anisotropic quartz or crack path.

FORCE / RESPONSE

Prescribed harmonic loading.

The top-face load has a 1 N peak resultant. A direct harmonic solve describes steady response. It does not model turning a drive on, repeated impacts, an acoustic beam or electrical conversion losses.

VALIDATION SCOPE

Keep distinct checks distinct.

Residual and energy checks examine numerical consistency. Refinement compares meshes. Neither is physical validation. The review scope separates all-record checks, reconstruction of the one public field, and one separately implemented reference solve. It shares NumPy/SciPy within this project; it is not an outside laboratory or physical validation.

NEXT WEAKNESS / PLANNED, NOT EXECUTED

Residual spatial sensitivity.

The finer direct mesh changes the response by less in absolute terms at these six points, but the selected-set screens still fail. A further bounded verification plan must address that remaining sensitivity before broader frequency, material or delivery-device claims. No additional mesh, adaptive peak search or acceptance-gate change is performed by this M04 release.

04 / EXECUTABLE RECORD

Preserve the fixed scope.
Publish the actual outcome.

The frozen packages bind the plan, source, all 18 point dispositions, actual figures and the mandatory retained field. Both failed selected-set screens remain visible.