{
  "schema": "M04-public-review-index-1",
  "created_utc": "2026-10-06T23:02:28.362795+00:00",
  "review_archive": {
    "filename": "m04-independent-review-v1.zip",
    "bytes": 76745,
    "sha256": "ceb2d19286e96ab76bb46f7bc6a1085abcccfd1767e6b6caf74ee4d42f0f7a36",
    "members": 43
  },
  "author_core": {
    "filename": "m04-local-refinement-core.zip",
    "bytes": 575751,
    "sha256": "665aa05af0a87792cab6cc068e46623dc2edaa824810e921285e6b31e5128f8e"
  },
  "numerical_provenance_checks": 121,
  "scalar_records_checked": 18,
  "parent_anchors": 6,
  "public_fields_reconstructed": 1,
  "independent_direct_solves": 1,
  "all18_independently_resolved": false,
  "physical_trials": 0,
  "accuracy": [
    {
      "coarse_n": 12,
      "fine_n": 16,
      "max_relative": 1.8556387372013752,
      "passed": false
    },
    {
      "coarse_n": 16,
      "fine_n": 20,
      "max_relative": 0.4260512253254629,
      "passed": false
    }
  ],
  "reference_relative_differences": {
    "mass_norm_relative": 1.1236502914366158e-13,
    "compliance_relative": 1.1603171305966373e-13,
    "RMS_stress_relative": 1.0136088385155665e-13
  },
  "reference_output_monitoring": {
    "passed": false,
    "actual_output_bytes_retrospectively_verified": 388899,
    "memory_time_guard_confirmed": true,
    "historical_helper_preserved": true,
    "corrected_helper_not_historically_executed": true,
    "reference_solve_repeated": false
  },
  "fast_exact_core_replay": {
    "passed": true,
    "author_tests": 21,
    "reviewer_analytical_tests": 5,
    "file_only_regressions": 2,
    "private_reference_comparison_repeated": false,
    "core_external_raster_bytes_verified": false
  },
  "records": {
    "INDEPENDENT-M04-AUDIT.json": {
      "path": "INDEPENDENT-M04-AUDIT.json",
      "sha256": "d12640f6ebf8875f7396b6197283cccb243b4400b79d38d574d12f419989e717"
    },
    "REFERENCE-PATH-INCIDENT.json": {
      "path": "REFERENCE-PATH-INCIDENT.json",
      "sha256": "f123cc0b89518b63535d4e14622fddc41ed571ae4f95fa23236ea5d742ca3d43"
    },
    "EXACT-PUBLIC-REPLAY.json": {
      "path": "EXACT-PUBLIC-REPLAY.json",
      "sha256": "d60b68b434ce62023f061cacc9e1a880007b223db4b3878052f85a0207cd758b"
    },
    "PUBLIC-FIGURE-AUDIT.json": {
      "path": "PUBLIC-FIGURE-AUDIT.json",
      "sha256": "3bfb6ba3989353f03b6f1f36b004bb543e8ead8cb934461a1bfb3e41fb684b31"
    },
    "SOURCE-CLEARANCE.json": {
      "path": "SOURCE-CLEARANCE.json",
      "sha256": "3bdf7e19683070b7294021c18faba7cd583950f28130b86f0b7ec23b57617b6c"
    },
    "PUBLIC-FILES.json": {
      "path": "PUBLIC-FILES.json",
      "sha256": "862bc64571bd6c9d944bc7913c123f0cfd3e97471a9f11e1a19190ef5bd537cf"
    }
  },
  "scope": "Within-project consistency only. Both unchanged5%targeted accuracy screens fail; six samples are not a full-band or continuum bound. Historical output-monitor coverage failed and is disclosed. Fast replay requires one explicit guarded regeneration to repeat the private-vector comparison.",
  "reviewer_archive_exact_smoke": {
    "passed": true,
    "seven_tests": true,
    "fast_checks": 118,
    "figure_data_checks": 17,
    "receipt_sha256": "aee695339f1f577040a0244d871edae9a61642495ff943ed5e3b7a59aad1c578"
  }
}
