Ashley Kalkowski / DESTROYING BOULDERS / Release 07

Change the contact.
Check the result.

Does the timing comparison survive a different model of the impact?

144 of 144 planned numerical integrations completed; status: complete. No physical fracture test is represented.

144 / 144Completed integrations
18 / 18Selected full traces verified
18 / 18Case/law mode screens passed
0Physical specimen tests

Question → controlled change → evidence

The same beam and commands. Three contact assumptions.

The earlier studies compared when to deliver two finite-energy impacts. Release 06 added structural modes. Release 07 changes the contact law while preserving the six selected conditions, inherited commands, common energy budget and declared acceptance screens.

The modeled delivery mechanism is two idealized mechanical striker contacts on a reference cantilever. It is not a complete motor, acoustic emitter, launcher or built device. Both protocols use 20 g total moving mass. The probe-estimated pair receives 9.9 mJ for its main event after a 0.1 mJ ideal probe charge; the unprobed fixed pair receives the full 10 mJ. Electrical supply, reset, transfer and apparatus costs are outside this boundary.

The main event lasts 0.17 seconds. The probe-estimated protocol inherits a 35-second settling assumption and a synthetic three-mode pre-probe ledger. Changing the contact law does not recalibrate that probe or add true online feedback.

LawExponentWhat is matched at 250 µm?What differs there?
Linear reference1Earlier model normalizationReference
Hertz exponent / force matched1.5Elastic and dissipative force componentsElastic storage is 20% lower; elastic tangent stiffness is 50% higher.
Hertz exponent / storage matched1.5Elastic storage and dissipative force componentElastic force is 25% higher; elastic tangent stiffness is 87.5% higher.

These are hypothetical constitutive comparisons. The matching indentation is an assumed normalization, not a measured material parameter. The nonlinear exponents do not establish Hertz geometry, restitution, plastic crushing or a calibrated rock contact. All three laws retain approach-only damping, passive elastic storage and zero tensile force after separation.

What the retained computation says

The contact assumption remains part of the result.

The seven-mode fine-step comparisons contain 9 resolved gains, 9 resolved declines and 0 unresolved comparisons across the available case/law settings. 18 of the 18 planned case/law settings pass the complete five-to-seven-mode screen. The displayed relative changes range from -8.636% to +10.985%. These are conditional model results at a common ideal mechanical energy budget, not evidence of measured breakage efficiency.

The six cases were selected using earlier results: they include the earlier favorable settings and difficult combined-error cases. They are not new independent trials or a random sample. Counts of positive and negative results cannot be read as a success probability.

Computed change in peak first-mode energy for six selected cases under three contact laws
Seven-mode fine-step comparisons. Hatched bars identify unresolved, invalid or incomplete screens. Lines and bars describe selected model conditions, not experimental repetitions.
ConditionContact lawAdaptive / fixed changeEnergy differenceDeclared comparison screens
I4-00Linear reference-0.8923%-0.03037 mJPass
I4-00Hertz exponent / force matched-0.8907%-0.03024 mJPass
I4-00Hertz exponent / storage matched-0.8948%-0.03175 mJPass
I4-01Linear reference+6.4599%+0.20434 mJPass
I4-01Hertz exponent / force matched+6.3139%+0.19955 mJPass
I4-01Hertz exponent / storage matched+5.9269%+0.19660 mJPass
I4-02Linear reference+10.7743%+0.32869 mJPass
I4-02Hertz exponent / force matched+10.9417%+0.33233 mJPass
I4-02Hertz exponent / storage matched+10.9847%+0.34845 mJPass
I4-F-errorLinear reference-6.8420%-0.23306 mJPass
I4-F-errorHertz exponent / force matched-6.9381%-0.23566 mJPass
I4-F-errorHertz exponent / storage matched-7.1945%-0.25552 mJPass
I4-H-errorLinear reference-8.6365%-0.28857 mJPass
I4-H-errorHertz exponent / force matched-8.5758%-0.28581 mJPass
I4-H-errorHertz exponent / storage matched-8.5564%-0.29866 mJPass
I4-H-zeroLinear reference+10.2612%+0.30309 mJPass
I4-H-zeroHertz exponent / force matched+10.3864%+0.30562 mJPass
I4-H-zeroHertz exponent / storage matched+10.3895%+0.31960 mJPass

Table: seven modes, 2.5 µs fine timestep. A value may remain visible even when its acceptance screen is unresolved or failed. The metric is peak reversible first-mode energy, not fracture work.

Eighteen selected complete histories

See the force and the energy ledger.

The frozen capture plan selects the reference, higher-frequency and combined-H-error cases, all three laws, both protocols, seven modes and the fine timestep. These are 18 selected histories from the 144 planned integrations. Other integrations retain parameters, summaries, sampled contact events and final ledgers; they do not have full saved waveforms.

Each complete trace retains 68,001 time samples and 25 float64 state columns. Independent reconstruction checks the saved force, indentation, contact storage, losses, work and modal/source energy. Additional recurrence checks evaluate saved RK4 transitions; they are consistency diagnostics, not new physical measurements.

Full numerical force and energy history for I4-00
Generated numerical force histories for both protocols and the adaptive main-event energy ledger. Contact-window axes and saved-step maxima are labeled.
Full numerical force and energy history for I4-02
Generated numerical force histories for both protocols and the adaptive main-event energy ledger. Contact-window axes and saved-step maxima are labeled.
Full numerical force and energy history for I4-H-error
Generated numerical force histories for both protocols and the adaptive main-event energy ledger. Contact-window axes and saved-step maxima are labeled.

The force charts display a labeled contact-time window. The energy ledgers cover the full main event. Every retained sample is supplied to the plots with path simplification disabled; dots identify maxima at saved timesteps. The 0.1 mJ prescribed probe charge is separate from the displayed 9.9 mJ adaptive main-event ledger.

Different checks answer different questions

Completion is not acceptance.

144 completed integrations passed their local checks; 0 completed with invalid local results or required trace checks. 0 solver failures, 0 interrupted runs and 0 unrun rows are retained explicitly. Trace status is separate: 18 verified, 0 failed, 0 omitted by quota and 0 pending.

Integration constraints, trace integrity, coarse/fine convergence, comparison resolution and the five-to-seven-mode screen are reported separately. The mode screen has a declared 2% energy-change threshold and rejects a resolved sign reversal or an unresolved comparison. Passing these checks supports a computation within the selected equations; it does not validate those equations against a specimen.

A separate computational implementation within this project checked 144 completed row records, 48 linear-reference parent replays and 18 complete traces. It reconstructed 1,224,000 saved RK4 transitions. All declared checks in that integrity review passed. Independent here means a separate computational implementation within this project, not an outside laboratory. It is not calibration against a real contact.

Independent review JSON · Every planned integration · Figure provenance · Comparison data CSV

Reproduce and inspect

A small core package. Individual full traces.

The core includes the new model, runner, checks, tests, frozen plan, per-run JSON records and portable review/plot scripts. It depends on the unchanged release 04 base and release 05–06 add-ons. The large NPZ traces are separate downloads with hashes and schemas.

Base 04 · Add-on 05 · Add-on 06 · Core file manifest

Extract into a new workspace and preserve the original archives. Place each downloaded NPZ in efficiency/results/iteration07/traces/; the core already includes its JSON sidecar. Python, NumPy and Matplotlib are separate dependencies. The package performs computation and does not control hardware.

python -m unittest discover -s efficiency -p "test_iteration07.py" -v
python reviews-r07/test_trace_checks.py --efficiency-root efficiency -v
python reviews-r07/test_independent_audit.py --efficiency-root efficiency -v
python reviews-r07/audit_runs.py --efficiency-root efficiency --output independent-r07-check.json
python reviews-r07/plot_verified.py --efficiency-root efficiency --audit independent-r07-check.json --output reproduced-r07-figures

The commands above verify and plot the downloaded frozen evidence. To run a fresh matrix into a separate output folder, see README-R07.txt in the core. Runtime and timestamps can differ; do not overwrite the original evidence while comparing numerical outputs.

Core archive SHA-256
5cfa47f5c417e2af30deda51f2ae1536a1bee4775c75a2ea2828f1d20c980c71

Trace / input conditionFull statesSchema / verificationSHA-256
I4-00
Linear reference
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONda5149dcb8b6506e663c09122f8604d5604f07314cfd00aba9bd58ad10be7ab8
I4-00
Linear reference
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.16 MB
68,001 samples
JSONe790fd35e9f3039757f7280ee4f6e0d15662ad8b6ba98c829821af36b2f2e1e4
I4-00
Hertz exponent / force matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSON30e5393d91590362ac484bb00ad917e0004ed280695d4f3d318fbbc228942835
I4-00
Hertz exponent / force matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONf613e945557704b7704c0af94d544f35926431d78d5c917221f837e9c42b2202
I4-00
Hertz exponent / storage matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.16 MB
68,001 samples
JSON51691ff266ae33d8ed8fb68bd2d4fb0dd18fef2bd5790eabedd53b6f1352e8ce
I4-00
Hertz exponent / storage matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.16 MB
68,001 samples
JSON2d684e2e6fea71445c36330c48976f1daca5177b6faaf8fc0af555ec674c2be9
I4-02
Linear reference
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.14 MB
68,001 samples
JSONe82b11f7d29a875b4c9845b7a73001383c87df2139e43a37fe36f202610c470f
I4-02
Linear reference
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSON01795287d5758861b0aa07b7639a81ab60403e5c6e714727bfd2d0496f7bbea3
I4-02
Hertz exponent / force matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONeaf821eefaf58a6273a388cc6eb5b52f154c4b69d9a23390c6ddd3bb85ad00b6
I4-02
Hertz exponent / force matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSON038b381e2e81e2c503f6d7735a2bcba026d1fcefc0e043400c178b5158e34835
I4-02
Hertz exponent / storage matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONe0ebf1df98ebcfbe9541b352836a7c730a8786d4e6019466983c5eb68575e8b5
I4-02
Hertz exponent / storage matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONd05bc747193faeede449ccb819a7c4ee3f972b89f20f396d095bdac2913d5579
I4-H-error
Linear reference
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONbedc518162e0c5d1709e614e0f38f15765ca571a0846caa025edddf80bdbd037
I4-H-error
Linear reference
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSON3b59909e141b81d3311e0772e15f6521c20ed9960e0c974de05b41bbb4151bc0
I4-H-error
Hertz exponent / force matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.18 MB
68,001 samples
JSON36f5a7c967915890bb71e4f1741e3e36001e2389d59263ae56a41692b94782f4
I4-H-error
Hertz exponent / force matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSONb3c1940b53a9b322c51e99af027b8031d13b2fb7c3db19506c9099fb6688c1f7
I4-H-error
Hertz exponent / storage matched
adaptive / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.18 MB
68,001 samples
JSON6fb091177fff9d65d0c31e9bfc7e9b6f6067fea669cde746226981a9db74ec11
I4-H-error
Hertz exponent / storage matched
unprobed_fixed / 7 modes
NPZ ↓ · 9.17 MB
68,001 samples
JSON8940c2ced5aa3f4879968dd8e5a64f06fa50c6e4ae873c255303cd56400e2193

The next physical question

Measure the interface that the model assumes.

A useful next step records synchronized force, relative indentation and motion during loading, unloading and rebound for a known specimen and contact geometry. Fit competing laws using the same calibration data, then compare their force histories, energy losses and response on withheld conditions. Both simple laws may fail.

Transfer to quartz, diamond, rock, logs or large steel requires material- and geometry-specific evidence. Controlled splitting additionally needs independently calibrated fracture initiation and crack propagation. Neither this numerical release nor the CAD gallery establishes minimum device size, arbitrary split paths, mining throughput, hardware efficiency or patent novelty.

Research direction: Ashley Kalkowski. Computational implementation and review used Codex assistance. Established mechanics and dependency terms remain attributed in the packages. No new blanket reuse license is granted by this page.

Return to the run explorer