DESTROYING BOULDERS / Research note

Measure the energy, then judge the timing.

Why Ashley Kalkowski’s vibration research compares energy transfer, contact conditions and robustness before claiming an improvement.

By Ashley KalkowskiComputational research

A frequency is not an energy source

Resonance can change how strongly an object responds to a drive. The driver still supplies the energy, and contact losses, damping, and changes in the object determine how much remains available.

For this project, the important question is whether timing improves useful energy transfer under a fair comparison. A larger response alone cannot answer that if the compared systems also differ in their contacts or available energy.

What the comparisons revealed

Initial numerical comparisons showed that some apparent gains from using two sources could be explained by the assumed aggregate contact properties. When the single-source comparison was given matching aggregate properties, those particular responses were equivalent in the model.

This is a useful finding for the research process: contact conditions must be treated as part of the experiment. They cannot be left as an unnoticed change while attributing the result to synchronization.

The comparisons track a reversible vibration-energy quantity in an elastic reference model. That quantity is not the energy required to create new fracture surfaces, nor a measured saving in rock-breaking energy.

What an efficiency claim must survive

Candidate improvements need equal input budgets, explicit contact assumptions, an energy ledger, numerical convergence, and tests under conditions excluded from the original search. Later specimen tests must also account for the energy used by the complete equipment, including any supporting load.

The intended physical outcomes are split completion, deviation from the selected plane, unwanted damage, elapsed time, total input energy, and repeatability. Those outcomes have not yet been physically measured in this project.

Relevant published work

Contact ultrasound and percussion already have a documented history in rock interaction. That makes established rock-drilling research a useful reference, while leaving the controlled-splitting question to be tested on its own terms.

  1. NASA research on ultrasonic and sonic rock drilling — contact-assisted rock removal, a different outcome from a complete prescribed split.
  2. Experimental research on wedge splitting of granite and gneiss — a reference for controlled crack propagation under mechanical loading.
Research journalAshley Kalkowski · October 2026