{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "id": "M03-direct-whole-grid-spatial-comparison",
  "status": "FROZEN_REVIEWED_PLAN_MAIN_EXECUTION_HELD",
  "question": "Separate the direct n10-to-n12 mesh difference from144-mode approximation differences at every original sampled frequency, without changing the specimen, forcing or damping.",
  "geometry": {
    "side_m": 0.02,
    "mesh_order": [
      10,
      12
    ],
    "tetrahedra_per_cell": 6,
    "element": "linearTET4; exact frozen M01/M02 Freudenthal mesh and consistent mass",
    "fixed_boundary": "all displacements at bottomz=0",
    "other_boundaries": "free except uniform downward top traction"
  },
  "material": {
    "id": "structural_steel",
    "E_pa": 210000000000.0,
    "rho_kg_m3": 7850.0,
    "nu": 0.3,
    "source": "Exact frozen rounded material input; no fitting or new measurements"
  },
  "forcing": {
    "resultant_peak_n": 1.0,
    "traction_peak_pa": 2500.0,
    "direction": [
      0,
      0,
      -1
    ],
    "complex_convention": "exp(+i*omega*t); physical Ureal*cos(theta)-Uimag*sin(theta)"
  },
  "damping": {
    "kind": "Rayleigh",
    "reference_ratio": 0.01,
    "anchor_frequency_hz": [
      20000.0,
      200000.0
    ],
    "C": "alpha*M+beta*K",
    "alpha": "2*zeta*omega_a*omega_b/(omega_a+omega_b)",
    "beta": "2*zeta/(omega_a+omega_b)",
    "status": "Same unmeasured illustrative loss assumption as M02"
  },
  "frequency_grid": {
    "min_hz": 20000.0,
    "max_hz": 200000.0,
    "count": 161,
    "spacing": "numpy.geomspace; require exact equality to both frozen M02 CSV grids",
    "index_base": 0
  },
  "planned_main_direct_points": 322,
  "planned_mesh_workers": 2,
  "planned_main_eigensolutions": 0,
  "physical_trials": 0,
  "new_time_domain_integrations": 0,
  "execution_order": "n10then n12; each worker assemblesK/M/element gradients once, takes free-DOF submatrices once, then solves all161frequencies ascending. Each frequency is an individual durable record. No parallel workers or extra peak search.",
  "operator": "[(1+i*omega*beta)*K_free+(-omega^2+i*omega*alpha)*M_free]U_free=F_free; scipy.sparse.linalg.spsolve; constrained DOFs exactly zero",
  "reuse_boundary": "Reuse geometry, material matrices and free submatrices, not a numerical factorization from a different frequency. No reordered physics, modal reduction or residual correction in direct solves.",
  "parent_reference": {
    "M02_summary_sha256": "624acf9c1f9c0c7dfa48f29d0ecb30be86195cea1e1ce6fa05173e5cc30a66ca",
    "M02_plan_sha256": "963fa48290c1d70199b314d5451228be9131eb9e80670944b456d887f62fc922",
    "modal144_reference": "Use exact saved M02 complex compliance144 CSV columns on each mesh; no new eigenproblem or modal field reconstruction.",
    "exact_shared_direct_grid_indices": [
      0,
      83,
      160
    ],
    "M02_direct_record_indices": [
      0,
      5,
      11
    ],
    "anchor_replay": "Require exact floating-point frequency equality before comparing inherited direct compliance/stress/energy at20kHz,66,035.88395365438Hz,200kHz. No interpolation or added off-grid solves.",
    "replay_relative_tolerance": 1e-06,
    "reference_arrays_hash_frozen": true
  },
  "primary_metrics": {
    "compliance": "H=F.T*U/(1N)^2; complex m/N; load vector contains prescribed1N peak distribution",
    "direct_mesh_relative": "max_f abs(Hd10-Hd12)/max(abs(Hd12(f)),0.01*max_f abs(Hd12))",
    "modal144_vs_direct_each_mesh": "max_f abs(Hm_n-Hd_n)/max(abs(Hd_n(f)),0.01*max_f abs(Hd_n)) for n10and12",
    "whole_grid_threshold": 0.05,
    "denominator_floor_fraction_peak": 0.01,
    "low20kHz_direct_compliance_mesh_threshold": 0.05,
    "low20kHz_time_volume_RMS_stress_mesh_threshold": 0.05,
    "full_grid_stress": "Retain both curves and per-frequency relative differences as diagnostics only. No new band-wide stress acceptance gate is claimed as inherited.",
    "metric_boundary": "Full-grid scalar complex-compliance differences are NOT the displacement mass-norm criterion used in M02's12direct probes. Do not transfer the5%field-error interpretation.",
    "completeness": "Official whole-grid screens require all322records present, numerically valid and source-consistent. Otherwise report partial diagnostics with whole-grid acceptance not_evaluated, never pass missing samples."
  },
  "decomposition_diagnostic": {
    "definitions": "M=Hm10-Hm12;D=Hd10-Hd12;E10=Hm10-Hd10;E12=Hm12-Hd12",
    "identity": "M=D+E10-E12 pointwise in complex compliance",
    "common_scale": "S12(f)=max(abs(Hd12(f)),0.01*max_f abs(Hd12)) for ALL decomposition terms",
    "triangle_upper_bound": "abs(M)/S12 <= (abs(D)+abs(E10)+abs(E12))/S12",
    "cancellation": "Report complex signed terms and magnitudes separately; no positive fractions summing to100% or causal energy interpretation. A residual close to machine precision is algebra, not independent physical validation.",
    "identity_residual_tolerance": 1e-12,
    "identity_residual_normalization": "abs(M-(D+E10-E12))/max(abs(M),abs(D)+abs(E10)+abs(E12),1e-30)",
    "no_continuum_error_claim": true,
    "historical_metric_boundary": "M02 original fixed144mesh metric normalizes byHm12. M03 common-scale decomposition normalizes byHd12. Retain and label both separately; they need not have identical numeric maxima."
  },
  "per_point_evidence": {
    "record": [
      "id",
      "mesh_n",
      "frequency_index",
      "frequency_hz",
      "status",
      "complex_compliance_real_imag",
      "volume_time_RMS_stress_Pa",
      "mean_elastic_energy_J",
      "mean_kinetic_energy_J",
      "mean_input_power_W",
      "mean_Rayleigh_loss_power_W",
      "dynamic_residual_relative",
      "element_matrix_energy_relative_error",
      "power_balance_relative_error",
      "fixed_displacement_max_m",
      "solve_elapsed_s"
    ],
    "stress": "Unchanged constant-element tensor stress; global RMS=sqrt(sum(V_e*(VM_squared(real_sigma_e)+VM_squared(imag_sigma_e))/2)/sum(V_e))",
    "selected_raw_field_indices": [
      0,
      80,
      160
    ],
    "selected_raw_fields_each_mesh": true,
    "selected_raw_field_count": 6,
    "selection_reason": "Band endpoints and logarithmic midpoint fixed prospectively; independent reviewer preselected index80 on both meshes. No outcome-selected maximum.",
    "raw_field_payload": "Unrounded full displacement real/imag inmetres plus n/index/frequency and fixed conventions; geometry exactly regenerable from included engine. All6checkpoints are public-package requirements, not optional omissions.",
    "other_full_fields": "Computed for each point but not retained; only scalar/stress/energy records are retained elsewhere. State this storage boundary explicitly."
  },
  "numerical_validity": {
    "dynamic_residual_relative": 1e-08,
    "element_matrix_energy_relative": 1e-08,
    "harmonic_power_relative": 1e-08,
    "fixed_displacement_exact_zero": true,
    "unit_force_absolute_n": 1e-12,
    "mass_relative": 1e-12,
    "finite_all_record_values": true,
    "unchanged_m02_thresholds": true
  },
  "resource_budget": {
    "total_wall_s": 900,
    "mesh_worker_wall_s": 450,
    "one_worker_at_a_time": true,
    "blas_threads": 2,
    "worker_hard_aggregate_commit_bytes": 4294967296,
    "sampled_combined_commit_and_resident_limit_bytes": 4294967296,
    "monitor_interval_s": 0.1,
    "max_new_evidence_bytes": 16777216,
    "reserved_final_metadata_bytes": 1048576,
    "clock_scope": "Before tests/preflight through numerical records, summary and manifest; final receipt states elapsed through final serialization and any deadline overrun. Cleanup after forced termination is not a new solve.",
    "guard": "Exact tested M02 Windows Job Object guard, assignment-before-GO, no breakaway, kill-on-close; hardworker aggregate commit versus sampledresident/combined thresholds explicit. Unresolved Windows native peak counter is retained, not substituted for admitted-memory measurement.",
    "timing_basis": "M02n10 worker mean0.964833s and n12mean2.076917s times161 give155.34+334.38s. Reusing matrices may save time;900s is a stopping budget, not a completion promise.",
    "public_budget": "Author executable/source/scalar reports/6raw checkpoints/figures target<1.4MB compressed delivery; total public additions subject root's2.3MB ceiling. Do not remove required6fields or failed results to meet it; report a packaging limit instead."
  },
  "preflight": [
    "All inherited input/source hashes and exact161-point CSV grids",
    "Optimized pre-sliced direct operator versus frozen full-matrix solver on a smallmesh",
    "Affine/consistent-mass/unit-load and clamped displacement checks using frozen engine",
    "Complex decomposition cancellation and triangle inequality, with shared denominator and incomplete-grid rejection",
    "Configured Job Object limit/GO/timeout/oversized allocation refusal tests with unresolved peak counter preserved",
    "Atomic JSON failure/size cap/exact322IDs/partial-row bookkeeping",
    "Source review and root clearance before main sweep"
  ],
  "failures_and_preservation": {
    "row_statuses": [
      "completed_valid",
      "completed_numerically_invalid",
      "failed_solver",
      "failed_serialization",
      "stopped_timeout",
      "stopped_resource",
      "not_run_budget",
      "not_run_dependency"
    ],
    "on_point_solver_failure": "Preserve failed row, continue subsequent fixed points only if resources/source integrity permit. Failed/invalid points disable official full-grid acceptance.",
    "on_guard_or_budget_stop": "Terminate worker tree, retain every atomically completed record and selected field, record interrupted index if known, mark all remaining IDs explicitly. No adaptive smaller mesh/grid or hidden retry.",
    "on_parent_anchor_disagreement": "Persist that row as completed_numerically_invalid; continue the same fixed points within budget. Missing or failed exact shared-anchor replay disables every official whole-grid acceptance screen. No interpolation or hidden retry.",
    "source_hashes_before_after": true,
    "fresh_outputs_only": true,
    "original_M01_M02_untouched": true,
    "no_post_result_threshold_or_checkpoint_changes": true,
    "on_actual_source_or_input_hash_change": "Stop execution, retain all data and mark provenance_invalid; official acceptance disabled."
  },
  "interpretation": [
    "Directn10/n12 differences are mesh differences, not true continuum error.",
    "All161samples still do not bound continuous-frequency maxima.",
    "One homogeneous isotropic20mm steel cube does not establish quartz/diamond/rock fracture or material hardness.",
    "No forcing-delivery device, acoustic laser, actuator, hardware trial, peak-optimization or damage claim follows.",
    "Agreement in compliance does not establish agreement in the full displacement/stress fields."
  ],
  "main_execution_status": "HOLD_FOR_ROOT_AND_INDEPENDENT_FROZEN_PLAN_CODE_PREFLIGHT_CLEARANCE",
  "frozen_utc": "2026-10-06T21:59:19.488172+00:00",
  "reviewed_draft_sha256": "c0c1e7d7db55ed2d0c393e723ef192b5662962155e1548aeb7af7b6d5995385e"
}
