{
  "schema_version": "whole-system-test-scorecard/1.0",
  "prepared_date": "2026-10-06",
  "status": "PROPOSED PUBLIC TEST RECORD — NO DEVICE RESULT ENTERED",
  "purpose": "Compare complete energy-delivery systems on a defined specimen outcome, with measured uncertainty and fair controls. This is a measurement/interpretation contract, not operating instructions for destructive apparatus.",
  "device_branches": ["contact impact", "bonded or clamped vibration", "air-coupled acoustic", "liquid-coupled acoustic", "electrically driven actuator", "direct electrical material-loading research"],
  "branch_rule": "An electrical power supply is not itself a specimen-loading mechanism. Name the actual conversion/coupling process and model it separately. Do not treat thermal, electrohydraulic, electromechanical and acoustic outcomes as the same process.",
  "evidence_levels": [
    {"level": "E0", "meaning": "Concept or unbuilt design; no measured performance."},
    {"level": "E1", "meaning": "Numerical equations/implementation verified within stated assumptions."},
    {"level": "E2", "meaning": "Complete sensing and delivery chain calibrated on a reference specimen."},
    {"level": "E3", "meaning": "Specimen-specific predictions checked on observations withheld from calibration."},
    {"level": "E4", "meaning": "Repeated physical outcome comparison against declared matched controls."},
    {"level": "E5", "meaning": "New material/size/support regimes independently validated; domain stated."}
  ],
  "current_project_level": {"numerical_reference_models": "E1 within their individual documented scopes", "physical_delivery_system": "E0", "fracture_performance": "not demonstrated"},
  "identity_fields": ["release_id", "run_id", "device_revision", "specimen_id", "protocol_id", "baseline_id", "evidence_type", "execution_status", "UTC_start_end", "source_and_input_SHA256", "raw_data_SHA256"],
  "cards": [
    {
      "id": "C01",
      "metric": "Specimen and prediction domain",
      "record": ["measured dimensions and mass", "geometry file and coordinate system", "material and orientation", "flaws/notches/previous damage", "moisture and temperature", "supports, preload and contact positions", "calibration IDs and withheld-validation IDs"],
      "units": ["m", "kg", "K", "dimensionless moisture fraction with definition", "N"],
      "acceptance": "A named calibration/validation domain is documented. A new geometry, material or support regime is labeled extrapolation until checked.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C02",
      "metric": "Whole-system input energy",
      "record": ["declared electrical measurement boundary", "time-resolved real electrical power and instrument bandwidth", "driver/actuator energy", "probe and sensor energy", "launcher/reset/positioning energy", "auxiliary cooling/computation energy or explicit separately declared shared loads", "initial/final energy storage", "preload/gravity or other released stored energy", "measured recovery at the same boundary"],
      "units": ["W", "J", "s"],
      "calculation": "Integrate real power over the declared full cycle, including charging/reset where applicable. Report gross input, measured returned energy and net input separately; account for changes in stored energy without double counting.",
      "acceptance": "Every material energy source is measured or explicitly unmeasured. An unmeasured term is null with a reason, never silently zero. A joule at a mechanical contact is not a wall-plug joule.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C03",
      "metric": "Delivered specimen work and coupling",
      "record": ["synchronized calibrated traction/force and velocity at the stated interface", "contact area/preload/adhesive or coupling medium", "signed and positive/negative mechanical work", "recoverable specimen/fixture energy", "heating and other loss channels", "air/liquid source field, distance and orientation where relevant"],
      "units": ["N", "Pa", "m/s", "m2", "J", "K"],
      "calculation": "Contact work is integral of force dot interface velocity over time; distributed loading uses surface traction dot velocity. Coupling ratio uses a named compatible measured energy denominator and signed convention.",
      "acceptance": "The complete transfer chain is characterized. Raw piezo volts, sound pressure alone, nominal amplifier watts or ideal plane-interface transmission do not substitute for measured delivered work.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C04",
      "metric": "Timing, frequency and delivery fidelity",
      "record": ["measured mode and uncertainty", "measurement band and anti-aliasing", "clock synchronization/error", "sensor noise and quality-gate outcome", "commanded phase/arrival", "measured contact or field arrival", "latency and jitter", "drift, saturation and temperature dependence"],
      "units": ["Hz", "s", "rad", "declared sensor units"],
      "acceptance": "A command timestamp or generated tone is not assumed to equal specimen force timing. Rejected estimates and fallback actions remain visible.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C05",
      "metric": "Useful outcome",
      "record": ["predeclared task: response measurement, crack initiation, complete split, removal or fragmentation", "acceptance threshold", "inspection method and resolution", "completion time", "crack extension", "removed mass or fragment-size distribution", "failure and censored attempts"],
      "units": ["s", "m", "kg", "m2", "declared fragment-size quantiles"],
      "acceptance": "A vibration peak, visible surface mark or first crack is not silently counted as a completed accepted split. Outcome definition is fixed before seeing comparison results.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C06",
      "metric": "Controlled crack path and collateral damage",
      "record": ["target plane/surface in specimen coordinates", "measured crack surface/path", "RMS and maximum distance from target with weighting definition", "off-target crack volume/area", "acceptable fragment or removal geometry", "measurement uncertainty"],
      "units": ["m", "m2", "m3"],
      "acceptance": "Tolerance and reconstruction method are declared in advance. No crack yields unavailable path error, not a perfect zero. Notches and prestress are disclosed as part of the tested setup.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C07",
      "metric": "Fair controls",
      "record": ["ordinary fixed-loading baseline", "fixed-timing versus measured-frequency protocol", "off-mode or timing perturbation control where meaningful", "unexcited handling control", "full budget and moving mass", "same allowed setup/time/support/prestress", "contact geometry/stiffness matching or explicit differences", "probe-cost allocation"],
      "units": ["J", "kg", "s", "N", "m"],
      "acceptance": "The control is not weakened by charging it an unused probe, changing its coupling or excluding favorable conventional settings. Any unavoidable unequal resource is reported.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C08",
      "metric": "Repeatability and uncertainty",
      "record": ["planned attempts and replicate count", "randomized order or justified pairing", "independent specimen count", "measurement uncertainty", "between-specimen variation", "all exclusions and reasons", "held-out evaluation results"],
      "units": ["count", "metric-specific uncertainty units"],
      "acceptance": "All attempted trials are accounted for. Repeated calculations, timesteps or mode counts are not independent specimens. Confidence intervals require an appropriate design and enough information; none are invented from a small chosen matrix.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C09",
      "metric": "Engineering efficiency and throughput",
      "record": ["total cycle input energy", "accepted outcomes", "total elapsed processing/setup/reset time", "consumable/tip wear", "temperature and duty-cycle limits", "failure/retry burden"],
      "units": ["J per accepted outcome", "J/kg for defined material removal", "accepted outcomes/hour", "kg/hour", "currency per defined outcome with date and assumptions"],
      "calculation": "Across a declared trial set, energy per accepted outcome equals all measured trial/cycle energy divided by accepted outcomes; failures remain in the numerator. Zero accepted outcomes produces null with reason zero_successes. Report output quality and uncertainty alongside energy.",
      "acceptance": "A reduction in peak-response cost does not establish fracture efficiency or industrial economics. Electrical recovery and useful output are independently measured.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C10",
      "metric": "Complete device size, cost and assembly",
      "record": ["head dimensions/mass", "amplifier/generator and storage", "reaction/support and fixture", "sensor/cabling/cooling", "specimen handling", "complete delivered BOM cost", "assembly skill/tools and commissioning time"],
      "units": ["m", "m3", "kg", "USD with date", "hour"],
      "acceptance": "Small heads or stickers are reported separately from the entire required system. A component list under USD1000 is not a complete validated fracture-system price.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C11",
      "metric": "Numerical credibility",
      "record": ["equations and parameter provenance", "code verification", "energy balance/passivity", "time refinement", "mesh or retained-mode refinement", "contact-law uncertainty", "calibration versus validation split", "prediction error and domain"],
      "units": ["declared error units and dimensionless residuals"],
      "acceptance": "Working numerical screens are distinguished from rigorous error bounds and physical validation. A passing model is credited only for its validated outputs and assumptions.",
      "result": null
    },
    {
      "id": "C12",
      "metric": "Public evidence and replication",
      "record": ["immutable run manifest", "raw data and processing provenance", "software/dependency versions", "missing-history declaration", "figure-to-run linkage", "video timing/scale metadata", "negative and partial results", "license status and source attribution"],
      "units": ["SHA256", "UTC", "s", "m"],
      "acceptance": "Simulation, concept image and physical test labels remain distinct. Model or video publication does not establish device performance. A reconstruction is labeled a new computation; privacy and third-party assets are reviewed before export.",
      "result": null
    }
  ],
  "score_aggregation": "No arbitrary total score or leaderboard is assigned. Compare accepted outcome quality, full-cycle energy, time, uncertainty and domain side by side; an unmeasured essential field prevents the corresponding performance claim.",
  "scale_transfer": {
    "steel_beam": "Needs actual cross-section, length, grade, constraints and loading/failure mode; elastic resonance, buckling, yield, fatigue and brittle fracture are different questions.",
    "boulder": "Needs measured geometry, rock fabric, joints/flaws, support and representative calibration. Ton/mass alone does not identify frequencies or fracture requirements.",
    "mountain": "A heterogeneous, jointed, stressed geological volume with interacting boundaries is a new geomechanical problem. No finite-beam result, software license or scalar size rule establishes an operating limit or validated mountain-scale fracture prediction.",
    "current_claim": "No validated maximum specimen size or fracture capacity exists in the inspected project. Scaling requires new held-out material/geometry/support evidence, not just increasing a frequency or energy parameter."
  }
}
