{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "study_id": "DELIVERY-STUDY-01",
  "created_utc": "2026-10-06T17:22:35.200Z",
  "project": "DESTROYING BOULDERS",
  "research_direction": "Ashley Kalkowski",
  "status": "SOURCE_REVIEW_AND_PROPOSED_TESTS_NO_PROJECT_FRACTURE_VALIDATION",
  "scope": "Ten delivery-device families with evidence boundaries and proposed tests. This is a literature-backed research register, not ten working prototypes, a cost quote or a proof of optimality.",
  "source_review_rule": "Only primary research, government project records and manufacturer documentation are used. Access level is explicit; no inaccessible full article is claimed read. Source text and images are not redistributed.",
  "method_count": 10,
  "physical_project_fracture_tests": 0,
  "methods": [
    {
      "id": "M01",
      "name": "Instrumented impact and steel waveguide",
      "mechanism": "A striker launches an elastic pulse along a bar or through a contact tip; local tensile/reflected stresses can initiate fracture.",
      "delivery_device": "Instrumented striker, elastic bar or replaceable tip, reaction fixture, force/strain sensing.",
      "coupling": "Solid contact; actual preload, contact area, bar geometry and alignment determine transmission.",
      "evidence_scope": "Rock impact fracture demonstrated in laboratory specimens; our finite-mass contact model is a beam surrogate only.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S02",
        "S13",
        "S15"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Measure incident, reflected and transmitted energy, then compare one blow, repeated blows and feedback timing on matched coupons.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure striker mass and velocity independently.",
        "Record calibrated force and contact velocity, or appropriately separated bar strain waves.",
        "Check dispersion, reflection timing and dynamic equilibrium before inferring specimen stress.",
        "Measure fragment mass distribution and crack path; include equal-total-input single-impact baseline."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "striker mass",
        "velocity",
        "tip radius",
        "preload",
        "bar diameter and length",
        "pulse width",
        "spacing",
        "contact losses",
        "specimen defects"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "launcher energy",
        "reset energy",
        "fixture and waveguide mass",
        "lost/reflected energy",
        "tip wear"
      ],
      "major_limit": "A large steel beam can transport energy but adds inertia and modes; it does not supply energy or force an arbitrary mountain-scale crack.",
      "next_step": "Best immediate low-energy research branch: instrumented contact transfer. No fracture performance validated here."
    },
    {
      "id": "M02",
      "name": "Clamped shaker and adaptive resonant excitation",
      "mechanism": "A bonded or clamped actuator applies cyclic force; phase, amplitude and frequency tracking may improve work transfer into selected structural modes.",
      "delivery_device": "Electrodynamic shaker or bonded piezo source with amplifier, attachment and response sensors.",
      "coupling": "Contact with fixture and adhesive dynamics included.",
      "evidence_scope": "Rock resonance/nonlinear characterization is established; this project's timing gains and losses remain numerical beam results.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S03",
        "S12"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Determine whether a tracked mode improves measured energy transfer and damage under a fixed electrical-energy budget.",
      "testing": [
        "Map force-to-velocity frequency response and phase with calibration reference specimens.",
        "Measure ringdown/Q and repeat after remounting.",
        "Include detuned, fixed-frequency and random-timing controls.",
        "Measure temperature, fixture slip and adhesive nonlinearity; inspect damage independently of resonance shifts."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "force limit",
        "stroke limit",
        "drive frequency",
        "phase delay",
        "attachment stiffness",
        "sensor loading",
        "damping",
        "frequency drift",
        "thermal limit"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "amplifier wall input",
        "actuator cooling",
        "attachment energy",
        "reaction mass",
        "sensing power"
      ],
      "major_limit": "A measured natural frequency does not specify the force, stress or time required for fracture; amplitudes saturate under losses and device limits.",
      "next_step": "Use the existing research rig for characterization before designing higher-power hardware."
    },
    {
      "id": "M03",
      "name": "Contact ultrasonic horn and ultrasonic/sonic impact hybrid",
      "mechanism": "Piezoelectric motion is transformed by a horn and may drive a free mass into a drill or chisel tip.",
      "delivery_device": "Tuned piezo stack, horn, optional free mass, working tip, driver and controlled preload.",
      "coupling": "Localized solid contact, often with preload; the horn resonance and rock response are distinct.",
      "evidence_scope": "NASA/JPL reported drilling several rock types with a compact USDC research device.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S01"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Benchmark local removal rate and delivered energy against ordinary impact on the same material.",
      "testing": [
        "Calibrate tip displacement and electrical real power.",
        "Measure preload and force/velocity at contact.",
        "Record depth, removed mass, debris size, tip wear and temperature.",
        "Separate ultrasonic-only, impact-only and hybrid conditions."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "horn geometry",
        "preload",
        "free-mass dynamics",
        "tip shape",
        "duty cycle",
        "contact state",
        "debris clearance"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "driver efficiency",
        "horn heating",
        "cooling",
        "preload mechanism",
        "tooling wear",
        "material removal"
      ],
      "major_limit": "Small-head drilling evidence does not establish a compact device that splits an entire boulder cleanly.",
      "next_step": "Promising delivery benchmark for later local rock-removal studies; not claimed novel."
    },
    {
      "id": "M04",
      "name": "Airborne phased acoustic source",
      "mechanism": "An acoustic aperture steers or focuses pressure through air onto a surface.",
      "delivery_device": "Speaker or ultrasonic array, amplifiers, phase control, calibrated microphones and field mapping.",
      "coupling": "No solid contact, but energy must cross the air-solid interface; aperture, wavelength, standoff and impedance matter.",
      "evidence_scope": "Air-coupled ultrasound is demonstrated for inspection; no selected source validates efficient bulk rock splitting.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S04"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Measure source-to-object transmission and accessible surface motion before any fracture objective.",
      "testing": [
        "Map sound field and uncertainty in position.",
        "Measure incident/reflected acoustic power and object response.",
        "Compare against contact excitation at equal measured wall energy.",
        "Test whether focus and transmission survive surface roughness and angular errors."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "aperture",
        "frequency",
        "wavelength",
        "standoff",
        "phase error",
        "pressure amplitude",
        "surface geometry",
        "attenuation"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "all array channels",
        "electrical conversion losses",
        "radiation outside target",
        "air absorption",
        "cooling"
      ],
      "major_limit": "Low frequency offers long wavelengths and poor localization for a small aperture; higher frequency does not remove interface mismatch.",
      "next_step": "Keep as a falsifiable transmission study, not the lead boulder-fracture architecture."
    },
    {
      "id": "M05",
      "name": "Liquid-coupled focused ultrasound",
      "mechanism": "Focused acoustic bursts stress a specimen through liquid; internal stresses and cavitation can contribute differently.",
      "delivery_device": "Focused transducer or array, liquid bath or coupling boot, driver, hydrophone and fixture.",
      "coupling": "Non-contact with the active transducer but liquid-contact with the specimen; not airborne operation.",
      "evidence_scope": "5–15 mm artificial and natural urinary stones were fragmented in a primary water-bath study.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S05"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Characterize focal stress transfer into controlled brittle coupons, then compare material-specific damage.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure the actual pressure field with suitable calibrated instrumentation.",
        "Control dissolved gas, fluid temperature and water condition.",
        "Record cavitation indicators separately from specimen fracture.",
        "Measure fragments and energy per removed mass; retain unchanged specimens and no-cavitation controls where feasible."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "carrier frequency",
        "burst repetition",
        "burst duration",
        "focal volume",
        "alignment",
        "dissolved gas",
        "fluid temperature",
        "specimen impedance"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "driver power",
        "fluid conditioning",
        "cooling",
        "coupling enclosure",
        "transducer efficiency"
      ],
      "major_limit": "Kidney-stone fragmentation cannot be generalized to diamond or boulders; large-object coupling and path control remain unvalidated.",
      "next_step": "Research branch for later specialist facilities; no turnkey under-$1,000 fracture claim."
    },
    {
      "id": "M06",
      "name": "Electrical-pulse fragmentation and electrohydraulic shock",
      "mechanism": "Two distinct routes: dielectric breakdown through rock, or an electrical discharge in liquid that generates a pressure wave.",
      "delivery_device": "Purpose-built pulsed-power apparatus with electrode/coupling geometry and synchronized electrical, pressure and damage diagnostics.",
      "coupling": "Electrical field/current within the target versus pressure transmitted through liquid must be classified separately.",
      "evidence_scope": "Heated granite flakes fractured under electric pulses; separate water-discharge studies damaged mortar and characterized conductivity effects.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S06",
        "S07"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Reanalyze published energy and damage datasets before any apparatus design.",
      "testing": [
        "Retain the electrical pulse waveform and relevant energy boundary.",
        "Measure source energy, discharge energy and target damage separately.",
        "Control conductivity, saturation, electrode condition and initial temperature.",
        "Use CT or ultrasonic measurements plus visible fracture geometry; include sham/thermal controls."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "pulse duration",
        "pulse energy",
        "electrode geometry",
        "conductivity",
        "saturation",
        "temperature",
        "rock dielectric variation"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "charging and switching losses",
        "liquid handling",
        "electrode wear",
        "cooling",
        "containment and instrumentation"
      ],
      "major_limit": "This family is not 'electric resonance.' A demonstrated laboratory discharge is not proof of low total energy, precise crack placement or household assembly.",
      "next_step": "Literature and simulation branch only; no electrical construction recipe or hardware execution in this release."
    },
    {
      "id": "M07",
      "name": "Microwave or thermal pretreatment plus mechanical breakage",
      "mechanism": "Spatially uneven heating creates thermal stress and may weaken grain boundaries before mechanical cutting or splitting.",
      "delivery_device": "Controlled electromagnetic or thermal source with applicator, temperature mapping and follow-on mechanical test.",
      "coupling": "Microwave absorption depends on dielectric properties and mineral distribution; thermal transfer depends on boundary conditions.",
      "evidence_scope": "Microwave-assisted cutting experiments show rock-dependent weakening and mechanical-work changes.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S08"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Determine whether total energy and throughput improve after counting pretreatment and cooling.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure wall input, reflected energy when available and temperature field.",
        "Match treated and untreated lithology, moisture and geometry.",
        "Test strength/fracture toughness independently of cutting.",
        "Count heating, cooling and cutting time; measure total energy, debris and tool wear."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "dielectric properties",
        "moisture",
        "mineralogy",
        "source power",
        "dwell time",
        "field distribution",
        "cooling",
        "initial stress"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "source conversion",
        "reflected energy",
        "thermal losses",
        "cooling",
        "subsequent mechanical work"
      ],
      "major_limit": "Lower cutting force can coexist with higher total energy and cycle time; heating response is not universal.",
      "next_step": "Model heat and stress with measured material properties before claiming efficiency."
    },
    {
      "id": "M08",
      "name": "Laser thermal spallation or local cutting",
      "mechanism": "Absorbed optical energy heats a surface, producing spallation, melting or vaporization depending on conditions.",
      "delivery_device": "Industrial optical source, delivery head, focusing, purge/collection and temperature/energy diagnostics.",
      "coupling": "Optical line of sight; surface absorption and debris/plume shielding govern delivery.",
      "evidence_scope": "DOE-funded laboratory projects demonstrated rock removal and lithology-dependent specific energy.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S09"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Compare local material removal and total energy with mechanical alternatives on the same endpoint.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure optical power at the specimen and wall power separately.",
        "Quantify removed mass and scan the cavity.",
        "Record melting, recast layer, cracks and thermal damage.",
        "Include purge and cooling energy, exposure time and optical delivery losses."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "absorption",
        "spot geometry",
        "exposure time",
        "pulse structure",
        "scan speed",
        "purge",
        "moisture",
        "mineralogy"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "laser wall-plug conversion",
        "optics loss",
        "cooling",
        "purge",
        "debris handling"
      ],
      "major_limit": "A sharply focused beam can remove locally; this does not imply remote whole-object splitting with two tiny emitters.",
      "next_step": "Comparative literature benchmark; not an at-home build recommendation."
    },
    {
      "id": "M09",
      "name": "Hydraulic or mechanical wedge splitting",
      "mechanism": "An expanding wedge applies localized opening forces inside a prepared hole, exploiting tensile fracture.",
      "delivery_device": "Wedge/counter-wedge tool, reaction and pump or mechanical actuator, with a drilled or otherwise prepared access point.",
      "coupling": "Direct internal solid contact; free faces, hole layout, flaws and boundary stress govern crack path.",
      "evidence_scope": "Commercial rock splitting exists; cyclic hydraulic injection is separately studied for subsurface fracture networks.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S10",
        "S14"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Use this established process as the benchmark for a clean split, including preparation effort.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure force/displacement or hydraulic pressure/flow with calibrated sensors.",
        "Include hole-making time, input energy and wear.",
        "Scan fracture surface and deviation from intended plane.",
        "Repeat across rock batches, orientations and pre-existing defects."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "hole preparation",
        "wedge orientation",
        "opening displacement",
        "loading rate",
        "pre-existing cracks",
        "boundary confinement",
        "free-face geometry"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "drilling",
        "pump input",
        "hoses and cylinder mass",
        "friction",
        "handling",
        "wear"
      ],
      "major_limit": "A directed split is more credible with imposed local opening and geometry control, but a perfect arbitrary plane remains unguaranteed.",
      "next_step": "Best established comparator for the user's clean-split endpoint; hybrid acoustic monitoring can be studied without novelty claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "M10",
      "name": "Pulsed waterjet and waterjet-assisted breakage",
      "mechanism": "A localized jet creates impact loading and erosion; liquid entering cracks can add opening action.",
      "delivery_device": "Industrial pump, jet delivery head, motion/stand-off control and water/debris recovery.",
      "coupling": "Fluid impact contact at a target area; short-range jet delivery differs from remote airborne acoustics.",
      "evidence_scope": "Granite pulsed/continuous jet experiments quantify local erosion under matched outlet conditions.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S11"
      ],
      "useful_initial_goal": "Compare erosion volume and fracture morphology per whole-system energy at equal task completion.",
      "testing": [
        "Measure pressure and flow waveforms, wall power and nozzle condition.",
        "Hold target distance, motion, material and exposure constant.",
        "Scan pit/kerf geometry and inspect subsurface cracks.",
        "Compare continuous/pulsed modes by equal hydraulic work and equal total wall energy, separately."
      ],
      "variables": [
        "pressure waveform",
        "flow",
        "nozzle geometry",
        "stand-off",
        "repetition rate",
        "traverse speed",
        "water condition",
        "confinement"
      ],
      "whole_system_costs": [
        "pump efficiency",
        "pulse generation",
        "water handling",
        "nozzle wear",
        "recovery"
      ],
      "major_limit": "Pulsed pressure or deeper erosion is not equivalent to a controlled full-width split or better total efficiency.",
      "next_step": "Established external benchmark; specialist apparatus required for physical validation."
    }
  ],
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "S01",
      "title": "Ultrasonic/sonic drilling/coring (USDC) for planetary applications",
      "url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210001776",
      "year": 2001,
      "type": "NASA/JPL research preprint record",
      "access": "Official abstract read",
      "finding": "A piezoelectric horn, free mass and drill stem drilled granite, diorite, basalt and limestone. The record reports a 450 g device, operation at 5 W and less than 5 N preload, with a 20 kHz electrical drive and useful subharmonic motion.",
      "limit": "Reported research-device figures do not establish total installed system mass, drilling rate at every listed condition, boulder splitting, cost or reproducibility with a purchased generic transducer."
    },
    {
      "id": "S02",
      "title": "Dynamic characteristics and fracture process of marble under repeated impact loading",
      "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0013794422006440",
      "doi": "10.1016/j.engfracmech.2022.108926",
      "year": 2022,
      "type": "Primary experimental and numerical journal article",
      "access": "Publisher abstract and highlights indexed; full text not accessed",
      "finding": "Repeated impact tests on marble and a corresponding SHPB model examined dependence on impact velocity and impact number.",
      "limit": "Results are geometry, stress and material dependent; repeated impacts are not proof of automatic exponential resonance amplification or lower total energy."
    },
    {
      "id": "S03",
      "title": "The role of fast and slow dynamics in nonlinear resonant ultrasound spectroscopy of consolidated granular materials",
      "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-11854-6",
      "year": 2025,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher methods indexed; direct open unavailable",
      "finding": "Experiments used 25 by 25 by 140 mm sandstone prisms, glued PZT transducers, a power amplifier and laser vibrometry; metal controls assessed apparatus nonlinearity. Probing covered the specimen's first longitudinal resonance.",
      "limit": "Resonance characterization and nonlinear response are not proof of macroscopic fragmentation or a universal frequency for sandstone."
    },
    {
      "id": "S04",
      "title": "Air-coupled ultrasonic NDE: experiments in the frequency range 750 kHz–2 MHz",
      "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0963869502000129",
      "year": 2002,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher abstract indexed; direct open returned 403",
      "finding": "Air-coupled through-transmission and reflection were investigated. The study identifies the severe air/material impedance mismatch; contacting a launching transducer helps inject energy.",
      "limit": "Detection of transmitted ultrasound is not evidence of useful fracture-energy delivery. This is NDE evidence, not airborne boulder-fracture evidence."
    },
    {
      "id": "S05",
      "title": "Fragmentation of urinary calculi in vitro by burst wave lithotripsy",
      "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25111910/",
      "doi": "10.1016/j.juro.2014.08.009",
      "year": 2015,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article, PubMed abstract",
      "access": "Full abstract read",
      "finding": "Artificial and natural urinary stones, 5–15 mm in this study, were fragmented by focused ultrasound bursts in a water bath. Different transducers/frequencies produced different fragment-size distributions.",
      "limit": "Urinary calculi are not diamond, quartz, sandstone boulders or steel. Water coupling, finite focal volume and material-specific fracture behavior prevent direct scale-up claims."
    },
    {
      "id": "S06",
      "title": "Effect of high-voltage electric pulse stimulation on heated-granite: An experimental investigation",
      "url": "https://journal.hep.com.cn/jocsu/EN/10.1007/s11771-024-5619-2",
      "doi": "10.1007/s11771-024-5619-2",
      "year": 2024,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Official abstract read; full text requires access",
      "finding": "High-voltage pulses produced fracture networks in thermally treated granite flakes. Breakdown and damage depended on thermal treatment and pulse conditions.",
      "limit": "Heated flakes are not intact, unheated field boulders. The study does not establish a cheap universal electrical splitter or a precise straight crack."
    },
    {
      "id": "S07",
      "title": "Experimental Investigation and Mechanism Analysis on Rock Damage by High Voltage Spark Discharge in Water: Effect of Electrical Conductivity",
      "url": "https://pure.strath.ac.uk/ws/portalfiles/portal/112428323/Cai_etal_Energies_2020_Experimental_investigation_and_mechanism_analysis_on_rock_damage.pdf",
      "doi": "10.3390/en13205432",
      "year": 2020,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article in university repository",
      "access": "Full article read",
      "finding": "Water-mediated discharge experiments damaged cement-mortar specimens. Electrical conductivity changed discharge loss and damage; CT and ultrasonic transmission assessed internal changes.",
      "limit": "Mortar was a controlled analogue, not validated replacement data for every rock. Stored electrical energy, plasma energy, pressure-wave energy and fracture energy are different quantities."
    },
    {
      "id": "S08",
      "title": "Effect of microwave irradiation on the breaking and linear cutting of hard rock",
      "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0013794424008920",
      "doi": "10.1016/j.engfracmech.2024.110729",
      "year": 2025,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher abstract indexed; direct open returned 403",
      "finding": "Microwave pretreatment was combined with conical-pick cutting of sandstone, basalt and granite. The response varied by lithology; reported mechanical cutting work decreased under investigated conditions.",
      "limit": "A reduction in mechanical cutting work alone does not establish a reduction in total electricity, treatment time or cost after including microwave heating and auxiliary equipment."
    },
    {
      "id": "S09",
      "title": "Laser Drilling, project DE-FC26-00NT40917",
      "url": "https://netl.doe.gov/node/3671",
      "year": 2007,
      "type": "US DOE/NETL project results",
      "access": "Official project results read",
      "finding": "Laser-rock tests identified lithology-dependent spallation and melting regimes. Gas removal, exposure duration and secondary heating affected specific energy; thermal spalling could use less delivered laser energy than melting in tested regimes.",
      "limit": "This is localized material removal. Optical energy per removed volume is not wall-plug efficiency, and a focused optical beam is not an acoustic laser or a whole-mountain splitter."
    },
    {
      "id": "S10",
      "title": "Hydraulic rock and concrete splitters, Darda catalog",
      "url": "https://www.darda.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/darda-spg-c20-en-2024.pdf",
      "year": 2024,
      "type": "Manufacturer product documentation",
      "access": "Official manufacturer catalog indexed",
      "finding": "Commercial wedge splitters act inside drilled holes, with the wedge orientation used to influence splitting direction. The catalog distinguishes cylinder mass and splitting force.",
      "limit": "Manufacturer claims are not an independent project experiment. The pump, drilling, hoses and handling equipment belong in total mass, cost and energy. Natural defects may divert cracks."
    },
    {
      "id": "S11",
      "title": "Experimental Investigation on the Granite Erosion Characteristics of a Variable Cross-Section Squeezed Pulsed Water Jet",
      "url": "https://www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/13/9/5393",
      "doi": "10.3390/app13095393",
      "year": 2023,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher methods/conclusions indexed; direct open returned 429",
      "finding": "Granite erosion was studied with pulsed and continuous jets under matched outlet pressure, target distance and exposure time. Pressure measurements and erosion geometry supported the comparison.",
      "limit": "Matched outlet pressure is not necessarily matched wall-plug energy or hydraulic power. Local erosion or deeper pits do not demonstrate a selected full-depth splitting plane."
    },
    {
      "id": "S12",
      "title": "Seismic events miss important kinematically governed grain scale mechanisms during shear failure of porous rock",
      "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33855-z",
      "year": 2022,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher methods indexed; direct open unavailable",
      "finding": "Sandstone testing combined acoustic emissions, ultrasonic surveys and synchrotron CT with loading measurements. The work identifies fracture mechanisms not fully represented by seismic-event observations.",
      "limit": "Acoustic-event counts alone cannot be interpreted as crack area, fracture energy or complete damage without complementary measurements."
    },
    {
      "id": "S13",
      "title": "Determination of dynamic fracture parameters using a semi-circular bend technique in split Hopkinson pressure bar testing",
      "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0013794409000435",
      "doi": "10.1016/j.engfracmech.2009.02.001",
      "year": 2009,
      "type": "Primary experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher abstract and experiment overview indexed",
      "finding": "A notched semi-circular bend specimen with SHPB loading and crack-opening measurements was used to estimate dynamic fracture parameters in a granitic rock; force equilibrium is required for the stated toughness interpretation.",
      "limit": "Dynamic stress equilibrium, geometry validity and timing must be checked. A signal peak or nominal impact energy alone is insufficient."
    },
    {
      "id": "S14",
      "title": "Relaxation damage control via fatigue-hydraulic fracturing in granitic rock as inferred from laboratory-, mine-, and field-scale experiments",
      "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-86094-5",
      "year": 2021,
      "type": "Primary cross-scale experimental journal article",
      "access": "Publisher abstract indexed",
      "finding": "Cyclic and pulsed hydraulic injection was compared with monotonic injection using laboratory, underground and field observations; fracture patterns, permeability and seismicity were evaluated.",
      "limit": "Reservoir stimulation is a different endpoint from removing a free boulder or generating one accurate split. Branching fractures can be undesirable for the latter."
    },
    {
      "id": "S15",
      "title": "An investigation of impact breakage of rocks using the split Hopkinson pressure bar",
      "url": "https://open.uct.ac.za/bitstreams/c763e568-e68f-4072-99eb-472f8dde14bc/download",
      "year": 2006,
      "type": "Primary experimental university repository paper; journal labels it non-refereed",
      "access": "Repository article abstract indexed",
      "finding": "Blue-stone geometry affected absorbed energy and fracture probability. In these tests cumulative low-energy impacts required more total energy to break particles than a single impact.",
      "limit": "A specific negative result cautions against assuming smaller repeated blows always save energy; it is not a universal rule for every material or timed protocol."
    }
  ],
  "comparison_contract": {
    "objective": "Report a Pareto comparison across useful task completion, input energy, crack-path error, total device size/mass, total cost, throughput and collateral damage. Do not collapse these into a single arbitrary efficiency score.",
    "energy_boundary": "Measure whole-system external energy, including preparation, probe/sensing, delivery, reset, cooling, fluid handling and cleanup during an explicitly stated time interval. Record target-delivered energy separately when measurable.",
    "size_boundary": "Count actuator head and complete operating system separately, including tethered generator, reaction fixture, pump, cooling and delivery hardware.",
    "fairness": "Compare the same initial specimen distribution and the same endpoint: one split, local removal, or fragment size distribution. Do not compare drilling energy with split energy as though they were interchangeable.",
    "controls": [
      "Untreated/sham handling",
      "Equal-input-energy conventional baseline",
      "Equal-delivered-energy baseline where measurable",
      "Fixed versus adaptive schedule",
      "Remount and sensor-loading controls",
      "Randomized specimen allocation and blinded crack-path scoring"
    ],
    "evidence_sequence": [
      "Instrument calibration and bandwidth/uncertainty",
      "Reference material and repeatable coupon response",
      "Independently observed crack initiation and fracture morphology",
      "Hold-out specimens and material batches",
      "Scale-up with boundary and wave-propagation effects",
      "Field trial with complete energy/cost accounting"
    ],
    "minimum_run_record": [
      "run ID and immutable input/source hashes",
      "method and exact energy boundary",
      "specimen dimensions/mass/material/orientation/moisture/flaw map",
      "device head and installed system mass",
      "calibrations with range and uncertainty",
      "raw synchronized waveforms",
      "commanded and achieved source settings",
      "total external energy and delivered energy if measurable",
      "support and coupling conditions",
      "temperature and wear",
      "before/after images and mass balance",
      "planned target plane and measured crack path",
      "failed/unrun status and stopping reason"
    ]
  },
  "testing_strategy": [
    {
      "id": "T01",
      "name": "Low-amplitude transfer characterization",
      "purpose": "Separate actuator, attachment and specimen dynamics before increasing excitation.",
      "outputs": [
        "frequency-response function",
        "phase/coherence",
        "ringdown damping",
        "attachment repeatability",
        "force/velocity work"
      ],
      "limitation": "A resonance map is not a fracture map."
    },
    {
      "id": "T02",
      "name": "Energy-balanced dynamic test",
      "purpose": "Determine where supplied energy goes.",
      "outputs": [
        "incident/reflected/transmitted energy where valid",
        "contact work",
        "loss and residual ledger",
        "temperature rise"
      ],
      "limitation": "A modeled absorbed-energy peak is not measured fracture energy."
    },
    {
      "id": "T03",
      "name": "Controlled fracture coupon",
      "purpose": "Calibrate a material-specific crack criterion and path.",
      "outputs": [
        "load/displacement history",
        "crack-opening measurement",
        "high-speed images",
        "post-test fracture surface"
      ],
      "limitation": "Coupon calibration must precede predictions for irregular boulders.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S13"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T04",
      "name": "Independent damage sensing",
      "purpose": "Distinguish fixture changes, reversible softening and real cracks.",
      "outputs": [
        "ultrasonic response",
        "acoustic emissions",
        "optical/DIC observations",
        "CT where feasible"
      ],
      "limitation": "No single sensor proves all damage; acoustic emission can miss mechanisms.",
      "source_ids": [
        "S12"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "T05",
      "name": "Scale and transfer validation",
      "purpose": "Test an unchanged prediction on specimens outside calibration.",
      "outputs": [
        "prediction error",
        "time-to-task",
        "energy-to-task",
        "crack-plane error",
        "unplanned branching"
      ],
      "limitation": "Do not extrapolate across diamond, rock, wood and ductile steel with one constitutive law."
    }
  ],
  "research_hypotheses": [
    {
      "id": "H01",
      "claim": "An adaptive controller that estimates attachment loss and modal drift may improve delivered work per total input energy compared with frequency-only tracking.",
      "test": "Freeze controller and energy budget; use unseen couplings and specimens; compare against matched fixed and detuned baselines.",
      "status": "UNPROVEN_HYPOTHESIS_NOT_PATENTABILITY_FINDING"
    },
    {
      "id": "H02",
      "claim": "Low-energy acoustic monitoring could identify when to stop or redirect conventional wedge loading before excessive crack branching.",
      "test": "Predict a stop/redirect event before examining held-out fracture images; compare crack-plane error and total task energy.",
      "status": "UNPROVEN_HYPOTHESIS_NOT_PATENTABILITY_FINDING"
    },
    {
      "id": "H03",
      "claim": "Selecting between local contact vibration and conventional splitting using measured transfer and damage observables may outperform one universal resonant device.",
      "test": "Predeclare a selection rule and evaluate complete task cost, energy and failed attempts on held-out rock types.",
      "status": "UNPROVEN_HYPOTHESIS_NOT_PATENTABILITY_FINDING"
    }
  ],
  "design_decision": "Continue low-energy contact-transfer characterization as the practical first instrument. Keep hydraulic/mechanical splitting as the clean-split benchmark and treat liquid ultrasound and contact ultrasonic hybrids as evidence-backed later research branches. No family is declared globally most efficient.",
  "mountain_scope": "A steel bar transports finite mechanical work. A mountain introduces joints, confinement, gravity, stress redistribution and radiation losses; a small trigger could release pre-existing stored energy without supplying that released energy. That is uncontrolled instability, not a demonstrated clean, predictable split. No mountain experiment or unlimited-energy claim is proposed.",
  "publication": "This register contains paraphrased research summaries and project hypotheses. It does not transfer third-party rights, establish patent novelty, or apply an open-source license to unrelated project files."
}
